اگر کسی آن لائن پلیٹ فارم پر کوئی کرنسی خریدی جائے اور اسے یہ کہا جائے کہ اسے بیچنے کے بجائے ہمیں دے دیا جائے تو اس کی طرف سے یہ سہولت فراہم نہیں کی جاتی بلکہ اصرار کیا جاتا ہے کہ اسے بیچ کر ڈالر میں ہی ادائیگی ہوگی۔ لہذا ایسی ویب سائٹس پر کام کرنا شرعاً جائز نہیں ہے۔ البتہ اگر کسی آن لائن فاریکس ایکسچینج کے طریقہ کار کی نگرانی مستند علماء کرام کر رہے ہوں اور انہوں نے تحریراً اس بات کی گواہی دی ہو کہ اس کا طریقہ کار شرعاً درست ہے تو اس پر کام کرنا جائز ہوگا۔
Sir ap ye ghlt information pela rhe ha mene niche diye gae fatwa parha Waha Kahi nh lika ha forex trading ke jaiz hone ka usme to ye bi mentioned ha k jaiz nh qk k milkiyat nh milti apko assets pr
To sir Zara or research kren apki research bhot kmzor ha me to apko bhot acha researcher smj tha ta lekin ab malom pra kch bi nh ha apki research
Fatwa inlogo nay khud parha nahi or halal bhi kardia.
In ka fatwa khud mana karraaha hay kay halal nahi hi but dhatai ki had hoti hay.
Plus logo nay fatwa parish kiye hain already jo Haram kehrahay hain.
Masla ye nahi kay ye halal hay ya haram masla to ye hay logo ko research ka taana detay rehtay hain or ajj ek bachay say research karwakar forun Alhamdullilah forex trading Halal hay ki post dalti jab kay fatwa jo show karrhaya hain urdu wala woh incomplete hay or kaha allow kia hay usmai ?
English wolay ko inkay ek member nay challenge kardi hay usi council say detail fatwa.
Haram or halal ki tameez hi nikal gai hay.
Sahi kaha tha Allah kay Rasool saw nay maal momen ki fitna hay.
I wouldn't be surprised if they turned this into Halal via their so called podcast.
‘Ubadah ibn al-Samit (may Allah be pleased with him) who said: The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “Gold for gold, silver for silver, wheat for wheat, barley for barley, dates for dates, salt for salt, like for like, same for same, hand to hand. If the types are different then sell however you like, so long as it is hand to hand.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1587)
The absence of interest in your leverage arrangement is a major step toward compliance with Islamic principles.
Responsible Use of Leverage:
If you manage leverage responsibly (e.g., low leverage ratios, effective risk management) and avoid excessive risk, you mitigate concerns about gambling (maysir) or recklessness.
Constructive Ownership:
If your trading platform provides direct access to liquidity providers and immediate execution, it can be argued that you have constructive possession of the traded asset during the trade.
In Forex trading with an ECN broker, you don’t physically hold the currency, but you have “constructive ownership.” This means that when you buy a currency pair, you legally own it, even though it’s digital. Obv it has to be digital since I am doing Forex online.
The claim that you don’t own the currency in Forex trading is based on a misunderstanding. While you don’t physically possess it, your legal rights over the currency after the trade are recognized, making the transaction valid and, therefore, halal under Islamic principles.
Adnan bhai ye halal kaise hua Apne kaha ke agr buy trade lete hain to usme ham own karte hain currency ko Lekin CFD me to actual buying nhi hoti wo to contract base hai to ownership isko nhi kehte plzz stop from forex
اگر کسی آن لائن پلیٹ فارم پر کوئی کرنسی خریدی جائے اور اسے یہ کہا جائے کہ اسے بیچنے کے بجائے ہمیں دے دیا جائے تو اس کی طرف سے یہ سہولت فراہم نہیں کی جاتی بلکہ اصرار کیا جاتا ہے کہ اسے بیچ کر ڈالر میں ہی ادائیگی ہوگی۔ لہذا ایسی ویب سائٹس پر کام کرنا شرعاً جائز نہیں ہے۔ البتہ اگر کسی آن لائن فاریکس ایکسچینج کے طریقہ کار کی نگرانی مستند علماء کرام کر رہے ہوں اور انہوں نے تحریراً اس بات کی گواہی دی ہو کہ اس کا طریقہ کار شرعاً درست ہے تو اس پر کام کرنا جائز ہوگا۔
حوالہ جات
۔۔
محمد اویس پراچہ
دار الافتاء، جامعۃ الرشید
26/ محرم الحرام 1445ھ
واللہ سبحانہ وتعالی اعلم
مجیب
محمد اویس پراچہ
مفتیان
سیّد عابد شاہ صاحب / محمد حسین خلیل خیل صاحب
Sir ap ye ghlt information pela rhe ha mene niche diye gae fatwa parha Waha Kahi nh lika ha forex trading ke jaiz hone ka usme to ye bi mentioned ha k jaiz nh qk k milkiyat nh milti apko assets pr
To sir Zara or research kren apki research bhot kmzor ha me to apko bhot acha researcher smj tha ta lekin ab malom pra kch bi nh ha apki research
Isay kehtay hain andha bantay rewriyaaa
Fatwa inlogo nay khud parha nahi or halal bhi kardia.
In ka fatwa khud mana karraaha hay kay halal nahi hi but dhatai ki had hoti hay.
Plus logo nay fatwa parish kiye hain already jo Haram kehrahay hain.
Masla ye nahi kay ye halal hay ya haram masla to ye hay logo ko research ka taana detay rehtay hain or ajj ek bachay say research karwakar forun Alhamdullilah forex trading Halal hay ki post dalti jab kay fatwa jo show karrhaya hain urdu wala woh incomplete hay or kaha allow kia hay usmai ?
English wolay ko inkay ek member nay challenge kardi hay usi council say detail fatwa.
Haram or halal ki tameez hi nikal gai hay.
Sahi kaha tha Allah kay Rasool saw nay maal momen ki fitna hay.
I wouldn't be surprised if they turned this into Halal via their so called podcast.
Yar ya owner ship ya malkiyat ka hawala kahan sa lia ha konsi hadees ya ayat ha jo kehta hain Hamesha
‘Ubadah ibn al-Samit (may Allah be pleased with him) who said: The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “Gold for gold, silver for silver, wheat for wheat, barley for barley, dates for dates, salt for salt, like for like, same for same, hand to hand. If the types are different then sell however you like, so long as it is hand to hand.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1587)
Yar ya owner ship ya malkiyat ka hawala kahan sa lia ha konsi hadees ya ayat ha jo kehta hain Hamesha
No Interest (Riba):
The absence of interest in your leverage arrangement is a major step toward compliance with Islamic principles.
Responsible Use of Leverage:
If you manage leverage responsibly (e.g., low leverage ratios, effective risk management) and avoid excessive risk, you mitigate concerns about gambling (maysir) or recklessness.
Constructive Ownership:
If your trading platform provides direct access to liquidity providers and immediate execution, it can be argued that you have constructive possession of the traded asset during the trade.
In Forex trading with an ECN broker, you don’t physically hold the currency, but you have “constructive ownership.” This means that when you buy a currency pair, you legally own it, even though it’s digital. Obv it has to be digital since I am doing Forex online.
The claim that you don’t own the currency in Forex trading is based on a misunderstanding. While you don’t physically possess it, your legal rights over the currency after the trade are recognized, making the transaction valid and, therefore, halal under Islamic principles.
Adnan bhai ye halal kaise hua Apne kaha ke agr buy trade lete hain to usme ham own karte hain currency ko Lekin CFD me to actual buying nhi hoti wo to contract base hai to ownership isko nhi kehte plzz stop from forex
Please full fatwa upload krein jamia tur Rasheed jamia Karachi ka !! Jo aik pic mein show horha hai uss se kuch result nahi nikla !!